One of the biggest lessons I've learned as a manager is that keeping my boss informed isn't a sign that I don't have things under control. It's often the opposite.
Carrying It Alone
Throughout my career, I believed that good management meant handling everything myself. If an issue came up, I would work through it, solve it, and only involve my boss if necessary. I thought leadership meant putting out every fire on my own. No news is good. News means I couldn't handle it. Over time, I've learned that there is a difference between owning a problem and carrying it alone.
The Disagreement
It started with something small. Another department wanted new hires added to email distribution lists during onboarding — but without telling us which lists. They wanted IT to figure it out: look at the role, look at the team, and make a reasonable guess.
I pushed back. Our workflow is simple: access is requested, approved, and then granted. We don't operate on assumptions. Guessing leads to mistakes — someone ends up on a list they shouldn't be on, sees information they shouldn't see, or misses something they need. And when a guess is wrong, there's no accountability, because nobody actually asked for it. The decision belongs to the people who know what the new hire needs. Our job is to carry it out correctly.
What looked like a minor onboarding detail quickly turned into a larger conversation involving multiple departments, senior leaders, and questions around ownership and accountability.
Keeping My Manager Informed
In the past, I would have managed it myself and said nothing. Instead, I kept my manager informed, shared my concerns and frustrations, asked for guidance, and let him take the lead when the conversation moved into ownership territory.
In the end, leadership agreed: each department owns its own distribution lists, and IT maintains them. When a new hire needs to be added, the department includes it on the onboarding ticket. If it's not on the ticket, there's no one to hold accountable — and guessing leads to mistakes. The request-and-approve workflow held, and now there's a clear owner when something goes wrong.
What changed for me wasn't the situation — it was how I understood my role in it. Bringing him in wasn't admitting I couldn't handle it. It was giving him the visibility he needed to support me, and trusting that asking for that wasn't a failure. I also knew this could escalate quickly — and that he needed context to step in effectively if it did.
What Managing Up Looks Like
Managing up isn't forwarding every email or escalating every disagreement. It's giving your manager enough context to support you before they need it.
Loop them in early. The best time to inform your manager is before something escalates, not after. When a disagreement starts pulling in other departments or senior leaders, that's the signal. Nobody likes being surprised by a conversation they should have known about.
Bring the facts, not just the frustration. Explain what's being asked, what your process is, and why it matters. It's fine to share frustration — I did — but lead with the facts so your manager has something to act on.
Be clear about what you need. Advice, backup, or someone to take the lead? Saying it directly saves everyone time.
Keep ownership of your work. Informing your manager isn't handing them the problem. I still owned our process and the reasoning behind it. What changed was who carried the conversation once it became a question of ownership between departments.
Not Every Debate Needs a Winner
Not every disagreement has a winning response. Sometimes there isn't one. Sometimes the best move is to make your case professionally, ensure the right people are informed, and let other leaders weigh in. Disengaging isn't losing — preserving relationships and organizational trust is often more valuable than winning a debate. And I'll be honest: I don't always have the right answer. Debate around process and policy is healthy. It's how better decisions get made.
Being Right vs. Getting It Right
I still stand by the call I made. We don't guess, and access gets requested before it gets granted. Ownership, accountability, and the right process for the right situation still matter.
But a few years of management have taught me that being right about the process isn't the same as being the right person to settle the bigger question. Sometimes the best outcome comes from knowing when to hand the conversation to someone better positioned to have it.
Owning the problem doesn't mean owning it alone.